Domestic ViolenceCalifornia Penal Code Section P.C. 273.5(a)

What is Penal Code Section 273.5(a), a common charge for domestic violence, in California?

California Penal Code 273.5 is a serious legal statute that addresses the willful infliction of corporal injury resulting in a traumatic condition on certain victims, typically those in close personal relationships with the offender. This law is designed to protect individuals from domestic violence, ensuring that perpetrators are held accountable for their actions. Conviction carries a range of penalties, including imprisonment (in state prison for two, three, or four years, or in county jail for up to one year), a fine of up to $6,000, or both.

Who does it apply to?

The law applies only under specific relational circumstances between the offender and the victim, otherwise the alleged criminal act would fall under one of the other battery charges in California. Examples of the types of relationships that would trigger the domestic violence charge include:

Spouses or Former Spouses: Reflecting the domestic nature of this offense, the law covers injuries inflicted upon a current or former spouse.
Cohabitants: The law extends to those living together in a domestic setting, not necessarily married.
Intimate Partners: Including fiancés or individuals in a dating relationship, acknowledging the broader spectrum of domestic relationships beyond marriage.
Parents of Offender’s Child: Recognizing the potential for domestic conflict extending to co-parenting situations.

Cohabitation Definition (Subsection c):

The law clarifies that formal acknowledgment of a spousal relationship is not required to prove cohabitation, broadening the scope to include non-traditional domestic arrangements.

What Constitutes a Traumatic Condition? (Subsection d):

The statute defines “traumatic condition” broadly to include various forms of physical injury, explicitly including injuries from strangulation or suffocation. Case law makes it clear that basically any mark or minor (but apparent) injury could constitute a ‘traumatic condition.’ Furthermore, what constitutes a “traumatic condition” under Penal Code 273.5 is clarified a little in the California Criminal Jury Instructions (CalCrim). A traumatic condition is the result of an injury if:

Natural and Probable Consequence: The condition must logically follow from the injury, in a way that a reasonable person would anticipate under normal circumstances.
Direct and Substantial Factor: The injury’s role in causing the condition must be significant, going beyond minor or incidental contributions. It’s not required to be the sole cause, but it must be a primary driver.
Causation: There must be a clear causal link where the condition wouldn’t have arisen in the absence of the injury.

These criteria aim to ensure that the legal threshold for a “traumatic condition” is met with a rigorous evaluation of the circumstances surrounding the injury and its aftermath.

Enhanced Penalties for Repeat Offenders (Subsection f)

Specifies stiffer penalties for those with prior convictions of related offenses, reflecting the law’s intent to deter repeat offenders.
Because of how serious the penalties for a conviction are and how complicated proving and defending against this crime is, anyone charged with Domestic Violence in California should seek attorneys like the Law Firm of Gomez, Radford, & Rome who have extensive experience handling these cases right away.

Elements of the Crime of Inflicting Injury on Spouse, Cohabitant, or Fellow Parent Resulting in Traumatic Condition

For a conviction under Penal Code 273.5, the prosecution must establish several key elements beyond a reasonable doubt. Firstly, the defendant must have willfully inflicted physical injury. Secondly, this injury must have resulted in a “traumatic condition,” defined broadly to include any bodily harm, whether minor or severe. Lastly, the victim must have a specific relationship with the offender, such as being a current or former spouse, cohabitant, or parent of the offender’s child.

What are the Consequences of a Conviction under P.C. 273.5(a)?

The consequences of a conviction under Penal Code 273.5 are severe, reflecting the seriousness of the offense. It is categorized as a “wobbler,” meaning it can be charged as either a misdemeanor or a felony, depending on the circumstances. Felony convictions can lead to imprisonment in state prison for two to four years, while misdemeanors may result in up to one year in county jail. Any time spent in prison will automatically make the charge ineligible for expungement down the line. Additionally, fines can reach up to $6,000, and enhanced penalties apply for repeat offenders, including longer prison terms and higher fines.

How Can You Defend Against These Charges?

Defending against charges under California Penal Code 273.5, which addresses corporal injury on intimates, involves several potential strategies that hinge on undermining the prosecution’s evidence or presenting alternative explanations for the circumstances surrounding the alleged offense. Key defense strategies may include:

Lack of Willfulness: Arguing that the injury was not inflicted willfully, but rather was the result of an accident, inadvertence, or a misunderstanding, thereby negating the element of intent required under the statute.
Self-Defense or Defense of Others: Claiming that the defendant acted in self-defense or in the defense of others, especially if there is evidence suggesting the alleged victim was the initial aggressor or posed an imminent threat to the safety of the defendant or others.
False Accusations: Highlighting instances where the alleged victim might have motives to falsely accuse the defendant, such as jealousy, revenge, or the desire to gain an advantage in custody or divorce proceedings.
Insufficient Evidence: Challenging the credibility and reliability of the evidence presented by the prosecution, including the testimony of the alleged victim and witnesses, medical reports, and forensic evidence.
Questioning the Cause or Source of the Injury: Arguing that the injury does not meet the legal definition of a “traumatic condition” as outlined in the statute, which requires the injury to be a direct and substantial factor in causing a condition that would not have occurred without the injury.
Alibi/Identity: Providing evidence that the defendant was not present at the time and location where the alleged injury occurred, thereby making it impossible for them to have committed the act.
Mitigating Circumstances: Presenting evidence of mitigating factors that might reduce the defendant’s culpability, such as mental illness, duress, or provocation, although these defenses may not result in complete acquittal but can influence sentencing.

Each defense strategy requires a careful analysis of the facts of the case, the evidence available, and the specific circumstances surrounding the alleged offense. It is essential for defendants facing charges under Penal Code 273.5 to consult with experienced legal counsel to develop an effective defense strategy tailored to their situation.

What Other Charges Might Accompany Penal Code 273.5?

Charges under Penal Code 273.5 can be accompanied by other legal charges if the incident involved additional criminal behavior. This might include assault with a deadly weapon (Penal Code 245) if a weapon was used, or charges related to child endangerment (Penal Code 273a) if minors were present or involved in the incident. Often times, the defendant will also be charged with domestic battery under Penal Code Section 243(e) as well.

Hire Gomez, Radford, & Rome if you’re charged with violating California P.C.

If you’re facing charges under Penal Code 273.5, it’s crucial to seek competent legal representation. Gomez, Radford, & Rome, Los Angeles Criminal Defense Attorneys, are well-equipped to handle such cases. With their background as former prosecutors and significant felony trial experience, they offer expert defense services across Southern California, including for cases as serious as murder. Each defense strategy requires a careful analysis of the facts of the case, the evidence available, and the specific circumstances surrounding the alleged offense. It is essential for defendants facing charges under Penal Code 273.5 to consult with experienced legal counsel to develop an effective defense strategy tailored to their situation.

Don’t wait, visit our office or call today for a free consultation.

Call now to speak with an attorney!